John Muir and Teddy Roosevelt on a camping trip in Yosemite Valley: NPS
By Glynn Wilson –
COULTERVILLE, Calif. – Ted Roosevelt IV doesn’t like to put words in his great-grandfather’s mouth. But according to a letter signed by himself and three other decedents of the former Republican president, he’s pretty sure that President Theodore Roosevelt would have been “appalled” by an effort by House Republicans to allow mining near an expanse of wilderness in Minnesota.
He and his relatives visited Washington on the eve of the President’s Day national holiday to lobby Republican senators and wrote a letter urging against allowing mining upstream from the Boundary Waters Canoe Area Wilderness, a vast preserve of glacial lakes and boreal forests crisscrossed by canoe routes and hiking trails.
It was a remarkable rebuke of the Republican Party’s apparent retreat from the environmental ethos of the great Teddy Roosevelt, who protected around 230 million acres of public lands during his presidency.
“It’s not just this administration — it’s the G.O.P. collectively that is not as concerned about conservation as it should be,” Ted Roosevelt IV, 83, said in a recent interview with the New York Times.
Roosevelt, a Manhattan-based investment banker and a lifelong moderate Republican, traveled to Washington last week to meet with senators and their staff members about the Boundary Waters. His conservative credentials and his famous last name got him through the doors of several offices, although he declined to say which ones.
Off the top of his head, Roosevelt rattled off several conservation efforts by Republican presidents: Ulysses S. Grant established Yellowstone as the first national park. Abraham Lincoln protected Yosemite Valley by giving it to California as the first state park. And most recently, George W. Bush created a marine national monument in the Pacific Ocean southwest of Hawaii.
“I don’t see any Republican leadership on that scale today,” Roosevelt said.
President Trump, who has indicated that he will sign the measure to allow mining near the Boundary Waters, has sought to increase oil and gas drilling, mining and other industrial activities on public lands and waters across the country. His administration plans to permit new oil drilling in the Arctic National Wildlife Refuge in Alaska and across nearly 1.3 billion acres of U.S. coastal waters.
“There’s never been a president with zero interest in protecting the natural world until Donald Trump,” said Douglas Brinkley, a presidential historian at Rice University and the author of the book “The Wilderness Warrior: Theodore Roosevelt and the Crusade for America.”
The signers of the letter included two other great-grandsons of Theodore Roosevelt: Tweed Roosevelt, a businessman and family historian, and Mark Roosevelt, a onetime Democratic nominee for governor of Massachusetts. Kermit Roosevelt III, a law professor and a great-great-grandson of the former president, also signed.
“T.R. was active in preserving our greatest wilderness terrain on both the East and West coasts — it became one of the greatest enduring legacies of his life,” the four Roosevelts wrote to senators. “It is now time for all of you to get in the arena with him,” they wrote, a reference to a famous quote from the former president about the value of fighting valiantly for worthy causes.
The descendants added that they represented all three branches of Theodore Roosevelt’s family, stemming from his sons Archie, Kermit and Ted.
“The four of us below have never collectively co-signed a letter together, which should give an indication of how strongly we support voting no on this,” they wrote.
Kermit Roosevelt III declined to comment, saying in an email that he “would prefer just to let the letter speak for itself.” The other two Roosevelts did not immediately respond to requests for comment.
People might not associate Theodore Roosevelt, who was born in New York City and hunted bison across the American West, with wilderness in Minnesota. But he established the Superior National Forest, which encompasses three million acres in the state and includes the Boundary Waters, in one of his final acts as president.
U.S. water features are shown in greater detail to highlight the watershed near the proposed mine. Sources: Minnesota Natural Resources Department, U.S. Forest Service, U.S. Geological Survey, Twin Metals Minnesota via Save the Boundary Waters
The Boundary Waters has been at the center of a fierce dispute over a proposed copper and nickel mine for more than a decade. Twin Metals Minnesota, a subsidiary of the Chilean mining company Antofagasta, wants to build the underground mine in Ely, just upstream from the wilderness area.
Conservationists have fought to block the project, saying its operations could contaminate the region’s interconnected lakes and streams with heavy metals and sulfuric acid. They scored a victory in 2023, when the Biden administration imposed a 20-year moratorium on mining across more than 225,000 acres of the Superior National Forest.
But the House this month passed a resolution from Representative Pete Stauber, a Republican of Minnesota, that would overturn the moratorium. Senate Republicans plan to pass the measure in the coming weeks with a simple majority vote, rather than the 60-vote threshold required for many types of legislation.
Since both senators from Minnesota are Democrats, it is unclear which Senate Republican would sponsor the measure. Representatives for Senator John Thune, Republican of South Dakota and the majority leader, did not respond to a request for comment.
Representatives for Twin Metals Minnesota and Mr. Stauber also did not return requests for comment.
Ryan Callaghan, the chief executive of Backcountry Hunters & Anglers, a nonprofit group that wants to preserve access to the Boundary Waters for hunting and fishing, said he was grateful to have the Roosevelts on his side in the Senate fight.
“That name sure carries weight with a lot of people,” he said.
The 26th president continues to command broad respect, among figures including the top Trump administration official responsible for overseeing public lands. Doug Burgum, the interior secretary, frequently invokes Theodore Roosevelt’s conservation legacy in speeches, social media posts and emails to Interior Department employees.
While serving as the governor of North Dakota, Burgum also championed the construction of the Theodore Roosevelt Presidential Library in Medora, N.D. The library is set to open on July 4 to mark America’s 250th birthday, an occasion that the four Roosevelts highlighted in their letter.
“On Independence Day, three pillars of T.R.’s life will take central stage: leadership, conservation and citizenship,” they wrote. “It’s one thing for politicians to say they believe in these three pillars, and it’s quite another thing to act that way.”
___
If you support truth in reporting with no paywall, and fearless writing with no popup ads or sponsored content, consider making a contribution today with GoFundMe or Patreon or PayPal.
